Listen to this post and more on this week’s episode of the Deep Sy podcast.
I sat at a dinner table in the “guest house” at the headquarters of a large nonprofit where I was a summer intern. Most interns lived with host families, but the office was well into the public-transit-less suburbs of Washington, D.C., and the government still won’t give blind people driver’s licenses (rude). So the org put me up in the guest house.
Standing across the table was the one other unlicensed intern, an international student I will call Suresh. He set down big serving bowls of rice and curry. When he offered to cook food from his region of southern India, I thought it would be a nice moment of cultural exchange. For Suresh, it was also a chance to eat something other than the TV dinners, lunch meats, and other bland American foods, processed to within an inch of being compost, which stocked the guest house fridge.
He was audibly excited; the smile in his voice was clear. He put food on his plate and sat for a moment taking in the smell. He picked up his silverware. Then, voice quivering like he couldn’t resist what he was about to do, he said, in a rush, “I’m going to eat with my hand.”
The fork and knife clattered on the table, and the rice squelched with his scoop.
He reveled in the familiarity of the food and the breaking of his weeks-long, involuntary flavor fast. He explained, in not so many words, that at home he never ate with silverware except to convince those who adhere to White-people manners that he is civilized. His honest view on forks and such, which I’ve since heard repeated by people from geographically wide-ranging cultures, is the opposite of the American default. It boils down to: “I just washed my hands, so I know they’re clean, but I have no idea where this silverware has been.”
It’s not a bad argument. Put it up against “But eating with your hands can get messy,” and it seems reasonable to go either way.
If only the subject at hand were “what seems reasonable.”
Unfortunately, the subject is manners. Manners are not about reasonability, but “propriety.” What — and in turn, who — is proper. They are rules about which tiny, objectively harmless behaviors make you “discourteous,” “undesirable,” or “a nasty pig.”
I sometimes fantasize about following Suresh’s lead when eating, though for reasons unrelated to colonialism. Using silverware can be tricky without vision. For most meals, I can get 90% of the food on a fork with no problem. I use the other food on the plate, which I feel with the fork, to push a bite onto the utensil. Getting the remnants on there, however, is a chore because there is no longer anything to push against (I know people use knives or the lip of the plate for this, but I never got the hang of doing that sightless). Some lightweight foods, like many salads, are just difficult from start to finish because they’re too insubstantial to be a backstop. This is especially true if they are, tragically, served on a plate, so that I can’t use a bowl’s sides for leverage. Still, I follow the rules to placate those with fork-based identities, and the chef has to swallow the indignity of my plate being less than clean.
The judgment I am forestalling with forking is predicated on vision. I can’t see how, or if, you’re using a fork, and it’s hard for me to care. Why police harmless behaviors when you can’t even clock them? But I still have to follow the rules because sighted people will use them to evaluate my acceptability for social interaction, employment, and more.
Of course, I have to live by many more visual standards than table manners for the sake of propriety. I make sure clothes aren’t wrinkled or stained, hair is appropriately trimmed, ties are long enough (but not too long), and living spaces and offices are “presentable.”
One thing that always makes me smirk internally is when I pretend to make eye contact during job interviews. It’s a farce. Two seconds of thought would expose the charade. At any moment, the interviewer could think, “Why is he looking slightly to my left?” and the jig would be up. But everyone who gives interview advice says eye contact is crucial. So there I sit, every time, playing make-believe.
All these examples highlight a truth I have to keep track of so I don’t get lost in the silliness of what I’m doing. The actions that a society considers good manners have no inherent value. It’s fine (and inevitable) for people in a certain place to have behaviors they consider typical. But when social regulations are impossible, hard, or just unpleasant to follow, it’s okay to remember their arbitrariness — their discriminatory assumptions — and insist on their adaptability. Sometimes, like in a job interview, you won’t have the power to change anything. But often you can edit the rulebook.
As Suresh went for seconds, I reached the point where using a fork to scrounge what little food remained became difficult. My fellow intern, though, had shown me the irrelevance of fork people who aren’t in the room. I felt where the scraps of rice were with a finger on my free hand, ushered them onto the fork, and wiped the finger on my napkin.
I employ that technique to this day, except when I’m trying to get something from someone who might be a proud forker. Blind people need to know the manners of our various cultures’ sighted people so we can choose to follow them when we feel like it suits our aims. But there is no need for us to respect those manners beyond their utility.
And if you think I’m wrong, if sighted people’s preferences should be more valuable to me, then I will sit up, brush any crumbs off my shirt, look you straight in the … I don’t know, chin? and promise to be more reverent.
Unless you’re not offering a job. In that case, you can go lick a dirty fork.



I enjoyed this perspective, providing another reason why "manners" aren't inherently good and kind of discriminatory. I also live alone and pretty much always eat alone so can do what I want without proud forkers judging me. It's a shame we're not all bold enough to eschew silverware in front of everyone.
I love this Sy, especially "there is no need for us to respect those manners beyond their utility." Too many people forget that these rules are abritrary, created by sighted (and, in my case, neurotypical) people.